Study says civilians could take 4,100 Miami Beach police calls a year; commission has put off hearing it since February
A consultant's study urges six more public safety specialists and moving sworn officers out of desk jobs. It is on the Nov. 18 agenda for the ninth time.
Civilian public safety specialists could handle about 4,100 more Miami Beach police calls a year that now go to sworn officers, if the department hires six more of them, according to a consultant’s study the City Commission has been scheduled to discuss since February.
The study by Matrix Consulting Group is attached to discussion item R9 E on the commission’s Wednesday, Nov. 18 agenda. The clerk’s record shows the item was not reached at eight straight meetings, from Feb. 25 through Oct. 14.
What the study found
The commission asked in September 2024, at Mayor Steven Meiner’s request, whether hiring more civilian staff could free officers from desk work and put more of them on the street. The city chose Matrix after nine bids that ranged from $89,000 to the $100,000 limit, according to the city manager’s memo, which does not give the final price.
The public safety specialists, who wear uniforms but are not sworn officers, answered about 1,360 calls in 2024, most of them traffic crashes, thefts and hit-and-runs, the report says. Of about 6,300 calls of the kinds civilians can handle that came in between 8 a.m. and 10 p.m., the consultant estimates about 4,100 could be diverted, worth some 7,100 hours of officer time and about 9% of all calls residents and visitors made to police. Comparable agencies divert an average of 16% of their calls, the report says.
The report notes that about half of the specialists on the afternoon shift now spend their time directing traffic, which limits how many calls they can take.
Recommendations
Matrix recommends raising the number of public safety specialists from 12 to 18, with the new ones working daytime shifts on non-emergency calls, and creating a lead specialist rank to supervise them. It also recommends replacing sworn supervisors with civilian managers in units such as property and evidence and court liaison, adding civilian staff for payroll, body-camera video redaction and records requests, and filling vacant crime analysis manager and victim advocate jobs.
The memo says the cost of any changes has not been worked out. The administration recommends that the commission consider the findings in a future budget.
The commission meets at 8:30 a.m. Wednesday at City Hall, 1700 Convention Center Drive.
Sources
- City of Miami Beach — Nov. 18, 2026 commission agenda, item R9 E memo (police professional staffing and workload analysis)
- Matrix Consulting Group — Miami Beach Police Department Professional Staff Study, final report (Exhibit B to item R9 E)
- City of Miami Beach — Nov. 18, 2026 City Commission meeting agenda
See something wrong? Tell us.



Neighbors' comments
Comments are for people who live in Miami Beach, Surfside, Bal Harbour, Bay Harbor Islands, North Bay Village or Sunny Isles Beach. Keep it civil and on topic; the editor reviews first comments.