City says Normandy Shores' future "not a current topic" as Mid-Beach course gets $11.2 million
Normandy Shores' revenue grew 27% in two years, twice the Mid-Beach course's pace, but it gets about $740,000 for repairs. The contract to run both courses ends September 2027.
Update, 11:38 a.m. Friday: Commissioner Laura Dominguez, the first commissioner to answer Red Sidewalks’ questions, said the city should look at more investment in Normandy Shores, that the commission should review the Inspector General’s findings, and that North Beach residents should have a say before decisions about the course. Her full answers are under “What commissioners say,” below. Red Sidewalks sent the same questions to all six commissioners Friday morning.
Update, 11:33 a.m. Friday: Professional Course Management, which runs both courses, responded after publication. Steve Farrell, general manager of the two clubs, said in an email that the problems the Inspector General’s audits found have been corrected, including the daily withdrawal procedure; that Alberto Pozzi, PCM’s longtime managing director, now leads the company; and that no decision has been made on whether PCM will seek a new agreement when the current one ends Sept. 30, 2027. He pointed to PCM’s written responses in the audit reports, summarized below. He also said PCM told Miami Shores about two years ago that it would not renew its contract to run the village’s country club or take part in the bidding.
Miami Beach has set aside about $11.2 million to rebuild and repair the Miami Beach Golf Club in Mid-Beach and about $740,000 for repairs at its other course, Normandy Shores Golf Club in North Beach, according to the city’s adopted budgets. Asked about Normandy Shores’ future, the city told Red Sidewalks on Nov. 18 that it “is not a current topic of discussion.”
The gap comes as Normandy Shores’ business grows faster than the Mid-Beach course’s, and after two years in which the surplus from both courses went toward the Mid-Beach rebuild.
Normandy Shores nearly matches the Mid-Beach course in rounds played, 54,187 to 56,898 in fiscal 2025, and its revenue is growing more than twice as fast. It has about $740,000 set aside for repairs, roughly one-fifteenth of the Mid-Beach course’s $11.2 million.
Charlie Alvarez, a golfer and board member of the Biscayne Point Homeowners Association in North Beach, said in a statement to Red Sidewalks: “Normandy Shores is a hidden gem that deserves to shine. With revenues up 27% and more than 54,000 rounds played annually, the course has proven its value to Miami Beach. Yet while millions are being invested in the Miami Beach Golf Club, Normandy Shores continues to wait for meaningful improvements. As an avid golfer and neighboring HOA Board Member, I believe it’s time to modernize the clubhouse, elevate the amenities, and give North Beach a golf facility worthy of its residents and visitors. This isn’t about favoritism between courses; it’s about fairness, vision, and investing in a community asset with enormous potential.”
The numbers
Through the current budget year, the city has set aside about $11.2 million for the Miami Beach Golf Club, at 2301 Alton Road: $8,855,070 for the course renovation, $2.15 million for soil cleanup, and about $183,000 for carpet and painting. Another $1.36 million in clubhouse, cart barn and equipment work is planned for later years.
Normandy Shores, at 2401 Biarritz Drive, has $740,000: $255,000 to replace the clubhouse’s facade moldings, $250,000 for drainage pumps, $150,000 for shade at the driving range and $85,000 for mowing equipment.
What’s been put off at Normandy Shores
Normandy Shores’ own $2.15 million soil cleanup is scheduled for 2028 but has no money yet, according to the capital budget. Painting and a facility roof, $130,000 together, were planned for this year and are now set for 2028. Restroom and kitchen work is set for 2030.
A gap with a long history
In the late 1990s the commission decided the Bayshore course, now the Miami Beach Golf Club, would become a “high quality tourist destination” and Normandy Shores a residents’ course with lower fees, according to a 2012 city memo. The Mid-Beach course was rebuilt in 2002 for about $10 million; Normandy Shores reopened in December 2008 after the city spent more than $9 million, a 2010 city audit says.
The two courses together were projected to make a surplus of about $2.6 million in each of the last two budget years. Both times, the city moved that money into its pay-as-you-go capital fund “for the partial funding” of the Miami Beach Golf Club renovation, the budget books say. The books don’t say how much of the surplus each course earned.
The city projects the two courses will clear a combined $3.47 million this year. That money is counted in $14.9 million the budget sets aside for capital projects across the city; unlike the past two years’ surpluses, the budget doesn’t tie it to a specific project.
The Miami Beach Golf Club is expected to close for 18 to 24 months once work starts, with groundbreaking anticipated in 2028, according to an Oct. 14 commission memo.
Normandy Shores is growing faster
Normandy Shores’ revenue rose from about $3.8 million in fiscal 2023 to $4.8 million in fiscal 2025, up 27%, while the Miami Beach Golf Club’s rose 12%, to $7.7 million. Normandy Shores logged 54,187 rounds in fiscal 2025, close to the Miami Beach Golf Club’s 56,898.
The city expects both courses to bring in more money this year:
| Revenue, in millions | Fiscal 2024 | Fiscal 2025 | Fiscal 2027 budget |
|---|---|---|---|
| Miami Beach Golf Club | $7.35 | $7.70 | $7.74 |
| Normandy Shores Golf Club | $4.31 | $4.78 | $5.39 |
The fiscal 2027 budget raises Normandy Shores’ expected revenue by $1.16 million over the year before, more than the Miami Beach Golf Club’s increase of $986,000. It also says spending will rise at both courses “based on current operational needs,” to be covered by the added revenue, without giving amounts.
The budget books don’t show what each course costs to run or whether either course makes money on its own. The most recent per-course figures Red Sidewalks found are in the Inspector General’s 2024 audits. Before debt payments, the city lost $214,772 running Normandy Shores in fiscal 2019, which ended before the pandemic, and $364,861 in fiscal 2020, which included the pandemic’s first months and in which the club’s revenue fell 16%. The Miami Beach Golf Club made $1.28 million and $1.24 million in those years, as its revenue dipped about 5%, the audits say. A 2012 city memo reported Normandy Shores deficits of $479,956 in fiscal 2010 and $245,252 in fiscal 2011, including debt payments.
The island around the course
Normandy Shores is the only one of the city’s two golf courses inside a gated neighborhood. Since 1993 the island’s property owners have paid an extra property tax, through the Normandy Shores Local Government Neighborhood Improvement District, “for the purpose of providing security services,” according to the city’s budget resolutions. This year’s rate is 0.7364 mills, raising $385,000 for guards at the guardhouse, a roving guard and gate repairs.
The cost of the roving guard is split between the district and the city’s Parks and Recreation Department, “which oversees operations of the Normandy Shores Golf Course,” the fiscal 2027 budget says. This year the budget adds a second rover on the same terms, to watch the island’s two gates from 3 to 8 p.m.
The district’s levy rose from $341,000 to $385,000 this year while its rate barely changed, from 0.7305 mills, which means the taxable value of property on the island rose about 12% in a year, according to figures in the city’s budget books.
Elsewhere in North Beach, the city is putting rising property taxes to work through the North Beach Community Redevelopment Agency, which receives about $3.4 million a year in property tax growth to spend between 65th Street and 87th Terrace, east of Rue Notre Dame. Its advisory committee met in the Normandy Shores clubhouse on Nov. 10 to plan that spending. The golf course and the island sit just outside the agency’s boundary.
Who runs the courses
Both courses are part of the Parks and Recreation Department’s general-fund budget, and their golf fees, from green fees and carts to memberships and the driving range, go to the city, according to the fiscal 2027 budget. The city pays a contractor, Professional Course Management, to run both clubs. The company has run Normandy Shores since an interim agreement in October 2001 and signed its first full contract for both courses in 2003, according to a 2012 city memo. Its current agreement expires Sept. 30, 2027, the city said.
The commission twice renewed the company’s contract without competitive bidding, in 2007 and 2013, according to 2024 audits by the city’s Office of the Inspector General. PCM won a bid in 2018, and the city renewed that contract in 2023.
Under the 2018 contract, PCM was paid a management fee and an incentive fee tied to revenue, and it kept 95% of pro shop and food and beverage sales, paying the city 5%, the audits say. In fiscal 2019 that came to $892,300 in gross revenue for PCM at Normandy Shores, including a $125,000 management fee and a $49,220 incentive fee, and $2.16 million at the Miami Beach Golf Club, including $304,778 in fees.
PCM refused to give auditors its labor costs, calling them proprietary, so the audits couldn’t show its profit. Before labor, the auditors put PCM’s gross profit over the two years at $1.34 million at Normandy Shores and $3.25 million at the Miami Beach Golf Club. At Normandy Shores, they said, PCM took in the equivalent of 39% of the city’s gross revenue while the city paid “an overwhelming majority” of the club’s expenses, and the city likely wasn’t benefiting adequately. PCM disputed the calculation (see below).
What the audits found
The two audits, of fiscal 2019 and 2020, found the clubs well run but the city’s oversight of the contract weak. The auditors said both courses appeared in excellent condition, with a waiting list for memberships and few complaints, and Parks officials told them PCM had beaten the city’s financial targets. But the Inspector General said a “mutually supportive relationship” between the Parks department and PCM may have weakened the city’s enforcement of the contract, with approvals often given only verbally, and said it disagreed with waiving bidding without a sole-source or emergency reason.
Among the findings at one or both clubs:
- PCM could withdraw up to $100,000 a day from the city’s golf bank accounts to reimburse itself, without advance approval, under a procedure city finance and parks staff worked out with PCM that differed from the contract, finance staff told auditors.
- The city reimbursed what auditors called questionable expenses, mostly for food and beverage operations and paper goods: $18,951 at Normandy Shores and $31,484 at the Miami Beach Golf Club.
- Some membership, tournament and greens-fee discounts weren’t on the commission’s approved fee schedules or lacked documented approval, and locker fees were charged that weren’t on the schedules.
- At Normandy Shores, PCM employees whose pay the city covered gave paid private lessons during work hours, and auditors couldn’t verify those earnings.
- The Parks department hadn’t documented the maintenance inspections the contract requires, a gap a 2010 city audit also flagged.
Draft findings went to the city and PCM in late 2021. The final reports came out Sept. 18, 2024, after meetings the Inspector General described as lengthy and contentious, in which PCM disputed some findings and some were revised.
Professional Course Management did not respond by Thursday’s deadline. After publication, Steve Farrell, general manager of the two clubs, answered Red Sidewalks’ questions in an email Friday. His answers, in full:
- What is PCM’s response to these findings, and which does it dispute? “Please see attached OIG reports which include PCM’s responses to the OIG findings.”
- Have the issues been corrected, including the daily withdrawal procedure? “Yes.”
- Who leads PCM now? “Alberto Pozzi, PCM’s longtime Managing Director.”
- Does PCM plan to seek a new agreement when the current one ends Sept. 30, 2027? “No decisions have been made on this matter.”
What PCM and the city said
In a written response attached to both final reports, PCM said the audits’ findings came down to several billing errors, $4,152 in overbilling and $22,723 in underbilling, which it put at roughly a tenth of 1% of revenue and expenses, plus procedures that needed improvement and contract language that needed clarifying: “no fraud, no abuse, no waste or other improprieties,” it wrote. The company said it strongly disagreed with several findings, which it said rested on wrong readings of the contract, and said the auditors didn’t understand the golf business or basic accounting.
PCM said it follows the reimbursement procedure the Finance Department set up, moving money only after payroll is processed or checks are written, with a PCM executive approving each transfer and a monthly report to the city, and that it carries potential liabilities of more than $400,000 a month, for payroll and other costs, until the city repays it. It said the contract lets it adjust rates temporarily with the parks director’s or city manager’s approval, which it said needn’t be in writing, and that the discounted rates brought in more than $1.3 million at Normandy Shores over the two years. It said its staff gave lessons on the clock because a 2016 U.S. Department of Labor audit required it, and that Parks staff regularly inspect the club. It listed changes already made, including advance written approval of tournament rate changes since January 2022, and said it had sent the city checks for $735.61 in sales tax and $700 in pro shop payments the audit said were owed.
PCM also said the auditors’ profit estimate was wrong, because revenue minus the cost of goods sold is gross profit, not net income. It cited a 2018 National Golf Foundation review, commissioned by the city, that placed the Miami Beach Golf Club’s net operating income in the top 2% of municipal golf facilities in the country.
The Parks and Recreation Department, which asked for the audits, disagreed in whole or in part with 11 of the 12 Normandy Shores findings, agreeing that PCM owed the sales tax. It said none of the findings involved fraud, waste or a violation of law, that about $27,000 of roughly $24 million in transactions over the two-year audit period was processed in error, and that the auditor lacked golf industry expertise. It said the reimbursement procedure, which the Finance Department set up after meetings with Parks and PCM, is consistent with the contract, and that the departments would revisit it.
In its reply, the Inspector General’s office said it was “disappointed and concerned at the tone, and the unduly combative nature” of some responses, some of which it said weren’t fully accurate. It said the audits never claimed the courses were poorly kept; they tested whether PCM and the city followed the contract. It called the daily withdrawals “a material internal control weakness” that needed prompt correction and said neither PCM’s nor Parks’ response sufficiently addressed it. It rejected PCM’s reliance on discount approvals from former city employees dating to 2008. It said PCM, which wasn’t legally required to, refused to share its food and beverage labor costs, and that the office questioned the accuracy and completeness of the records PCM provided and its openness with the city. And while it agreed its figure was better called gross profit, it said PCM has little reason to hold down costs when its incentive fee is based on revenue alone.
The complete reports, with all the responses, are on the city clerk’s records site: Normandy Shores and Miami Beach Golf Club.
PCM’s website names Johnny LaPonzina as the Pembroke Pines company’s founder and president and lists the two Miami Beach courses among its properties. An obituary for Johnny Michael LaPonzina, 78, who died Nov. 13, says he owned or managed more than 20 golf courses over his career. It doesn’t name the company. Farrell said Friday that Alberto Pozzi, PCM’s longtime managing director, leads PCM now, and that no decision has been made on seeking a new agreement after Sept. 30, 2027.
Nearby Miami Shores, whose village-owned country club PCM also ran, picked a new operator this year. A village evaluation committee ranked Kemper Sports Management first among four bidders in February, according to a village notice; PCM was not among the four ranked. An April 30 special meeting of the Village Council was called to extend PCM’s contract by two weeks, to May 15, and to start Kemper’s contract that day, according to the village’s meeting notice. Farrell said in his email that PCM “informed the Village of Miami Shores some 2 years ago of our intention not to renew the contract for the management of the Miami Shores Golf Club nor would we be participating in the bidding process.”
What the city says
Asked about the courses, the city’s communications director, Melissa Berthier, answered Red Sidewalks’ questions by email on Nov. 18:
- On a change of management: “The current management agreement expires on September 30, 2027. Administration is currently evaluating next steps.”
- On selling or leasing either course: “No”
- On how the Mid-Beach design item fits the city’s plans: “The design and the management of are two separate issues.”
- On a public process for the courses’ future: “The future of Normandy Shores is not a current topic of discussion.”
The mayor’s office did not respond by Thursday’s deadline.
What commissioners say
Red Sidewalks sent the same five questions to each of the six commissioners Friday morning and is running their answers in full as they come in. The mayor’s office was asked separately (see “What the city says”).
Commissioner Laura Dominguez answered by email Friday:
“Thank you for reaching out. I think this is an important conversation, and one we should be having.”
1. What is your response to the story?
“I think we need to take a closer look at how we are investing in both golf courses. They are City-owned properties, and we have a responsibility to make sure they are well maintained and that public money is being spent wisely.
“I am particularly interested in understanding why Normandy Shores has not received more attention when it comes to improvements. It is an important asset for North Beach, and we should not overlook it.”
2. Should the City invest more in Normandy Shores? If so, in what, and how should it be paid for?
“Yes, I think we should look at additional investment. There are improvements that need to be evaluated, including drainage, flooding, the clubhouse, restrooms and general maintenance.
“The reported 27% increase in revenue over two years is worth looking at. I would like to understand how much the course is actually bringing in after expenses and what money can reasonably be reinvested into the property.
“Before committing to a specific amount, I would want a full assessment of the needs at both courses and a clear plan for funding the improvements.”
3. How should the City choose who runs the courses after the agreement ends? Should the contract be put out to competitive bid?
“These are public assets, and we should make sure we are getting the best possible management and value for residents.
“The next agreement should also have clear performance standards, regular financial reporting and stronger oversight. We should not simply renew a contract because that is what we have done in the past.”
4. Have the Inspector General’s findings been addressed, and should the Commission review them?
“I would like to know exactly where things stand. The Inspector General raised some serious concerns about financial oversight, including the ability to withdraw up to $100,000 a day without advance approval.
“I don’t want to assume those issues remain unresolved, but I also don’t want to be assured that they have been corrected. I would like the Administration to provide an update on each finding and explain what changes have been made.
“I absolutely believe the Commission should review this. We need to know that proper safeguards are in place when public money is involved.”
5. Should residents have a public process before any decision about either course’s future?
“Absolutely. These belong to the residents of Miami Beach. Any significant decisions about their future, management or major investments should involve public discussion.
“I especially want North Beach residents to have a voice in the future of Normandy Shores. It is an important part of that community, and residents should have an opportunity to weigh in before decisions are made.
“I want both courses to be successful, well maintained and financially responsible. We need to look at the facts, ask the right questions and make decisions that are in the best interest of our residents.”
Residents’ view
Residents and golfers who spoke with Red Sidewalks described Normandy Shores as a valuable city asset that has been left waiting while the Mid-Beach course gets millions, pointing to a dated clubhouse, drainage problems and security.
The Normandy Shores Homeowners Association, a voluntary residents’ group, did not respond by Thursday’s deadline to a request for its position.
Marvin Boritz, a Normandy Shores resident who lives on the course, said the clubhouse needs an upgrade inside. “It looks to me like a retirement home for Miami Beach,” he said in a phone interview. “You come in, that’s your first impression when you walk in, and it’s grotesque. It really is. The chandeliers, the lighting, everything about that place.” An upgrade, he said, could make it “a facility that people would feel proud walking into,” and he said the menu has “never been changed or really updated.”
Boritz said arriving to play is harder at Normandy Shores than at the Mid-Beach course: “Not very attractive when you approach it from the outside and pulling through the parking lot. You’re always looking for a spot, and people double park.” He said the group of golfers he plays with, who play five or six times a week, prefers the Miami Beach Golf Club and comes to Normandy Shores when events there bump them. He praised the Mid-Beach course’s check-in, where staff meet golfers with carts at a staging area, and its larger pro shop.
Rollie Hernandez, who retired from Miami Beach Fire Rescue and has lived on the course for 26 years, said security needs attention along with the clubhouse. He said he would like to see park rangers patrolling the course around the clock, every day of the year. Golfers, he noted, pay more than $120 a round.
He said he has watched property values on the island rise sharply over the years, and “it’s time” for some of that tax revenue to come back to Normandy Shores.
Hernandez said he suggested a two-story clubhouse when the current one was built: “That way, you could sit in the afternoons or in the morning time on the deck up top. And enjoy a sunrise.”
Geoff Green, a longtime Normandy Shores resident, said in a statement to Red Sidewalks: “I don’t think the course itself needs much in the way of renovation unless we are talking about course drainage. Drainage remains a significant issue at Normandy. Regular course closure due to flooding impacts revenue, employee retention and reputation. The clubhouse is certainly dated and could use a refresh in a major way. The community at large enjoys the bar, the patio and the restaurant, but it’s stale and needs a redo.”
The $740,000 the city has set aside for Normandy Shores includes $250,000 for drainage pumps.
Former Commissioner Kristen Rosen Gonzalez, who ran for mayor in 2025, said of Normandy Shores in an email to Red Sidewalks: “We have a five-star course and clubhouse with a three-star renovation. We can do much better. That said, I know residents like the Happy Hour and friendly staff at restaurants. Both clubhouses cater exclusively to residents and that is important too.”
How to weigh in
Residents can write to the mayor and commissioners, whose addresses are listed on the city’s website:
- Mayor Steven Meiner: [email protected]
- Commissioner Monica Matteo-Salinas: [email protected]
- Commissioner Laura Dominguez: [email protected]
- Commissioner Alex J. Fernandez: [email protected]
- Commissioner Tanya K. Bhatt: [email protected]
- Commissioner David Suarez: [email protected]
- Commissioner Joseph Magazine: [email protected]
Anyone can also speak at a commission meeting during the public comment period, the Dr. Stanley Sutnick Citizens’ Forum, held at 8:30 a.m. and 1 p.m. or as soon as possible after. Speakers get two minutes, or a period the mayor sets, and no appointment or advance notice is needed, according to the city clerk. The commission holds a workshop at 4:30 p.m. Monday, Nov. 30, and its next regular meeting Wednesday, Dec. 9, at City Hall, 1700 Convention Center Drive. City Hall offices can be reached at 305-673-7035.
The wife of Red Sidewalks’ editor serves on the association’s board.
Sources
- City of Miami Beach — FY 2027–31 Adopted Capital Budget, Volume 1
- City of Miami Beach — FY 2027 Adopted Operating Budget
- City of Miami Beach — FY 2026 Adopted Operating Budget
- City of Miami Beach — Nov. 18, 2026 commission agenda, item C2 G (memorandum)
- City of Miami Beach — Oct. 14, 2026 commission agenda, item R7 AQ
- City of Miami Beach — April 19, 2012 committee memo on golf course management
- City of Miami Beach — Oct. 15, 2010 internal audit of the golf club management agreements
- City of Miami Beach — North Beach CRA
- City of Miami Beach Office of the Inspector General — OIG No. 24-19, Normandy Shores Golf Club audit, with PCM's and the city's responses (Sept. 18, 2024)
- City of Miami Beach Office of the Inspector General — OIG No. 24-20, Miami Beach Golf Club audit, with PCM's and the city's responses (Sept. 18, 2024)
- City of Miami Beach — Mayor and Commission
- City of Miami Beach — City Commission meeting dates
- Commissioner Laura Dominguez — email to Red Sidewalks (Nov. 20, 2026)
- Professional Course Management — email to Red Sidewalks from Steve Farrell, general manager, Miami Beach and Normandy Shores golf clubs (Nov. 20, 2026)
- Professional Course Management — Johnny LaPonzina
- Legacy.com — Johnny Michael LaPonzina obituary
- Miami Shores Village — Recommendation to award, RFP 2025-11-02, Management of the Miami Shores Country Club (Feb. 10, 2026)
- Miami Shores Village — Village Council special meeting, April 30, 2026
See something wrong? Tell us.



Neighbors' comments
Comments are for people who live in Miami Beach, Surfside, Bal Harbour, Bay Harbor Islands, North Bay Village or Sunny Isles Beach. Keep it civil and on topic; the editor reviews first comments.